TL;DR: A good idea with a messy execution.
Source: NetGalley, so many thanks to the publisher!
Plot: A handmaiden of Persephone cursed to be a siren in one time line and her arrival in Roanoke in another.
Characters: Not great, not great at all.
Setting: This was probably the most frustrating.
Fantasy/Romance: The fantasy was part of the story’s tools, but it wasn’t overly strong. The romance though – yikes.
Summary:
Before, Scopuli. It has been centuries since Thelia made the mistake that cost her the woman she loved—Proserpina, the goddess of spring. As the handmaidens charged with protecting Proserpina when she was kidnapped, Thelia and her sisters are banished to the island of Scopuli and cursed to live as sirens—winged half-woman, half-bird creatures. In luring sailors to their deaths with an irresistible song, the sisters hope to gain favor from the gods who could free them. But then ships stop coming, and Thelia fears a fate worse than the Underworld. Just as time begins to run out, a voice emerges, Proserpina’s voice, and what she asks of Thelia will spark a dangerous quest for their freedom.
Now, Roanoke. Thelia can’t bear to reflect on her last moments in Scopuli. After weeks drifting at sea alone, Thelia’s renewed human body—a result of her last devastating sacrifice on Scopuli—is close to death. Luckily, an unfamiliar island appears on the horizon: Roanoke. Posing as a princess arriving on a sailboat filled with riches, Thelia infiltrates the small English colony. It doesn’t take long for her to realize that this place is dangerous, especially for women. As she grows closer to a beautiful settler who mysteriously resembles her former love, Thelia formulates a plan to save her sisters and enact revenge on the violent men she’s come to despise. But is she willing to go back to Scopuli and face the consequences of her past decisions? And will Proserpina forgive her for all that she’s done?
Thoughts:
Thelia was a handmaiden to Proserpina (Persephone), and after the events of that story, she is cursed with her sisters to be a siren. Many years later she washes up on Roanoke Island and becomes involved with the colony there before it’s inevitable disappearance. This sounds fascinating, especially with the sapphic romance pitched in the blurb. Unfortunately I found myself growing more annoyed and inevitably angry by the end.
My primary two complaints were the romance and the setting. The romance in Roanoke, that girl was a walking red flag. While I understand ‘the time’ the ‘religion’, so on and so forth. This is a modern book written with modern sensibility (I’ll return to that). The amount of times our romantic interest said things to Thelia that made me say “No. Absolutely not.” was way too many times. And to the biggest gripe – the absolute erasure of the Algonquian people that were present on Roanoke Island. The author says simply it wasn’t her story to tell – but completely ignoring and erasing those people and what happened to them felt even very nefarious and lazy. There are people you could consult, there are sensitivity readers. She could have chosen to educate herself or in the best case scenario simply placed the story at another point and time. Not only are they erased, but the characters around Thelia are recognized as colonizers. They talk oh so briefly about what they’re doing and how it bothers them maybe a bit, but it continues. So no. I didn’t like this.
Ultimately I can’t recommend it. The complete ignoring of the actual setting and people therein – it’s lazy to me. If you’re going to set a story in a time and place that is wrapped up in history so tightly you need to address all of history. This was deeply frustrating for me.

Leave a Reply